Why: Our projection gives each side a goal or more – 66% for a score at each end. Orlando City SC dropped all three points in their latest game. 1.40 is thin for a single; pair it with another steady pick.
Answers come from this page's own numbers. 18+, bet responsibly.
Columbus Crew v Orlando City SC prediction, odds and steady pick
The fixture
Columbus Crew host Orlando City SC at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field, US Open Cup fixture, Thursday 17 September – the whistle goes at 00:00 WAT.
Form check
Columbus Crew, previous 5: LLWLL Most recently they went down to New York Red Bulls 0–1 on home soil. Home record in that spell reads 1 won, 2 lost from 3. Per match: 1.2 for, 1.8 against.
Orlando City SC, previous 5: WWWDW Most recently they got past Toronto FC 3–0 on home soil. The attack is humming at 2.2 per match.
Orlando City SC hold the form edge: 2.2 points per match against 0.5.
Head-to-head file
Most recent meeting (13 Apr 2026): Columbus Crew 1–1 Orlando City SC.
Goal sheet
Projected: Columbus Crew 2.2, Orlando City SC 1.4 – a combined 3.7. That projection leans high – three-plus goals at 71%, goals at both ends 66%. Recent games involving either club have mostly cleared 2.5.
Side tickets
Result split: Columbus Crew 56% · draw 19% · Orlando City SC 25%.
Goals at each end: yes on our sheet – 66% at 1.40.
Price worth a look: Columbus Crew to win at 1.91 – our sheet 56%, the price implies 52%.
The ticket we printed
Printed before kick-off: Goals at both ends – 66% on our sheet, best price 1.40. Scoreline we print: Columbus Crew 2–1 Orlando City SC. Graded on normal time only. A steady pick can still lose – 18+, keep stakes level and small.
Result split
Columbus Crew56%fair 1.80 · @1.91
Draw19%fair 5.20 · @3.60
Orlando City SC25%fair 3.97 · @3.00
3.67Expected goals
2.22Columbus Crew xG
1.45Orlando City SC xG
66%Both score
71%Over 2.5
Six likeliest scorelines
2–19%
1–18%
3–17%
2–27%
2–06%
1–26%
Goal sheet: Columbus Crew 2.2 – 1.4 Orlando City SC. Even the top line lands rarely – correct scores are for pocket-change stakes.
What is the steady pick for Columbus Crew v Orlando City SC?
Our ticket reads Both teams to score, rated 66% on our sheet with a best price of 1.40.
Who will win Columbus Crew vs Orlando City SC?
We give Columbus Crew 56%, a draw 19% and Orlando City SC 25%.
How many goals does SteadyPredict project for Columbus Crew v Orlando City SC?
Our goal sheet totals 3.7. Three or more goals: 71%. A goal at each end: 66%.
Which scoreline do you print for Columbus Crew v Orlando City SC?
We print Columbus Crew 2–1 Orlando City SC from a projected total of 3.7 goals.
When is Columbus Crew vs Orlando City SC?
Columbus Crew vs Orlando City SC (US Open Cup) kicks off on Thursday 17 September 2026 at 00:00 (West Africa Time) at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field.
SteadyPredict figures mix our ratings and goal sheet half-and-half with market prices. Times shown in your own time zone. Every percentage is an estimate – 18+ only.