Why: Two sides who leave space behind; roughly 3.0 goals expected. At 1.20 it pays little on its own – it fits better as one line of a ticket.
Side tickets
Match result1 ✓52% · @1.88
Double chance1X ✓76% · @1.22
GG / NGGG ✗62% · @1.55
GoalsOver 1.5 ✗80% · @1.20
Correct scoreCS 2–1 ✗10%
Ask about this match
Answers come from this page's own numbers. 18+, bet responsibly.
Columbus Crew v New York City FC prediction, odds and steady pick
The fixture
Columbus Crew host New York City FC at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field, US Open Cup fixture, Thursday 21 May – the whistle goes at 00:30 WAT.
Form check
Columbus Crew, previous 5: DLLWW Most recently they shared the points with Philadelphia Union 1–1 on the road. Home record in that spell reads 3 won, 1 lost from 4. Averaging 2.2 goals per outing – a busy front line.
New York City FC, previous 5: DWWDL Most recently they shared the points with New York Red Bulls 1–1 on the road. Away record in that spell reads 3 won, 0 lost from 4. The attack is humming at 2.5 per match.
Goal sheet
Projected: Columbus Crew 1.9, New York City FC 1.2 – a combined 3.1. Expect an open afternoon: 58% for a third goal, 62% for a score at each end. Recent games involving either club have mostly cleared 2.5.
Side tickets
Result split: Columbus Crew 52% · draw 25% · New York City FC 24%.
Cover the draw: Columbus Crew or draw – 76% at 1.22.
Goals at each end: yes on our sheet – 62% at 1.55.
The ticket we printed
Printed before kick-off: Match total reaches 2+ – 80% on our sheet, best price 1.20. Scoreline we print: Columbus Crew 2–1 New York City FC. Graded on normal time only. A steady pick can still lose – 18+, keep stakes level and small.
Result split
Columbus Crew52%fair 1.94 · @1.88
Draw25%fair 4.06 · @3.65
New York City FC24%fair 4.20 · @3.55
3.10Expected goals
1.89Columbus Crew xG
1.21New York City FC xG
62%Both score
58%Over 2.5
Six likeliest scorelines
1–110%
2–110%
1–08%
2–08%
1–26%
3–16%
Goal sheet: Columbus Crew 1.9 – 1.2 New York City FC. Even the top line lands rarely – correct scores are for pocket-change stakes.
Full price board: our number against the market
Market
Most likely
Chance
Fair odds
Bookmaker
Match result
1✓
52%
1.94
1.88
Double chance
1X✓
76%
1.31
1.22
Both teams to score
GG✗
62%
1.60
1.55
Over/under 1.5 goals
Over 1.5✗
80%
1.26
1.20
Over/under 2.5 goals
Over 2.5✗
58%
1.72
1.65
Over/under 3.5 goals
Under 3.5✓
63%
1.58
1.45
Half-time result
HT 1✗
40%
2.51
–
Half-time / full-time
1/1✗
33%
3.03
–
Correct score
CS 2–1✗
10%
10.28
–
Recent results
Columbus Crew – last 6
DLLWWW
17 May
@ Philadelphia Union
1–1
D
14 May
@ New York Red Bulls
2–3
L
3 May
vs Minnesota United FC
2–3
L
30 Apr
vs One Knoxville
4–1
W
26 Apr
vs Philadelphia Union
2–0
W
23 Apr
vs Los Angeles Galaxy
2–1
W
2.2Scored / game
1.5Conceded / game
83%Both scored
67%Over 2.5
New York City FC – last 6
DWWDLW
17 May
@ New York Red Bulls
1–1
D
14 May
@ Charlotte
1–0
W
30 Apr
@ New York Red Bulls
3–1
W
23 Apr
vs FC Cincinnati
4–4
D
19 Apr
vs Charlotte
1–2
L
15 Apr
@ Westchester SC
5–2
W
2.5Scored / game
1.7Conceded / game
83%Both scored
67%Over 2.5
Head to head
Our files hold no earlier meeting between Columbus Crew and New York City FC.
What is the steady pick for Columbus Crew v New York City FC?
Our ticket reads Over 1.5 goals, rated 80% on our sheet with a best price of 1.20.
Who will win Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?
We give Columbus Crew 52%, a draw 25% and New York City FC 24%.
How many goals does SteadyPredict project for Columbus Crew v New York City FC?
Our goal sheet totals 3.1. Three or more goals: 58%. A goal at each end: 62%.
Which scoreline do you print for Columbus Crew v New York City FC?
We print Columbus Crew 2–1 New York City FC from a projected total of 3.1 goals.
When is Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?
Columbus Crew vs New York City FC (US Open Cup) kicks off on Thursday 21 May 2026 at 00:30 (West Africa Time) at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field.
SteadyPredict figures mix our ratings and goal sheet half-and-half with market prices. Times shown in your own time zone. Every percentage is an estimate – 18+ only.